Best QB Battles in Camp

[The Legend Killer]

Interesting to see if any of the rookie QB can become the starter of thier new teams.

Some of the "starters" may be unseated, any correct me if I am wrong in guessing.

Colt Brennan VS Jason Campbell ~ Washington

John David Booty VS Tavarius Jackson ~ Minnesota

Brian Brohm VS Aaron Rodgers ~ GB

Chad Henne VS John Beck ~ Miami

Matt Ryan in Atlanta

Joe Flacco in Baltimore

Does aynone think any of these rookie has a legit chance to start.

[Irish]

Brennan. Campbell isn't too great, and Brennan is out to prove something. The Rainbow Warrior will get something done in training camp. I don't like JD Booty much either, but he has a legit chance to start over the thus far failed project of Tavares Jackson

[Browns17]

Originally Posted by The Legend Killer

Interesting to see if any of the rookie QB can become the starter of thier new teams.

Some of the "starters" may be unseated, any correct me if I am wrong in guessing.

Colt Brennan VS Jason Campbell ~ Washington

John David Booty VS Tavarius Jackson ~ Minnesota

Brian Brohm VS Aaron Rodgers ~ GB

Chad Henne VS John Beck ~ Miami

Matt Ryan in Atlanta

Joe Flacco in Baltimore

Does aynone think any of these rookie has a legit chance to start.

None of these Rookies have a chance to start the season except maybe Matt Ryan.

Joe Flacco is behind Boller and Troy Smith and I think Boller will win the job but not for long before Troy takes over and if he struggles they'll probably put Boller back in. Flacco won't/shouldn't see hardly any play this year unless they're planning on ruining him.

In Miami, it'll be Josh McCown vs. John Beck, Henne will be #3.

In Green Bay, the Packers drafted Brohm to be a number 2 QB for awhile, and are behind Rodgers 100%, which means that there's basically no battle between them.

Colt Brennan is not up for the starting position at all. It's Jason Campbell vs. Todd Collins if anything.

The Vikes will roll with Tarvaris no matter what, barring an injury. Booty will need time to develop. If Tarvaris struggles or gets hurt than you'll see Gus Frerotte or Brooks Bollinger if he isn't cut before they toss in Booty.

The real QB battles this year will be:
Starting QB battles:
Matt Leinart vs. Kurt Warner

Josh McCown vs. John Beck

Kyle Boller vs. Troy Smith

Jake Delhomme vs. Matt Moore

Matt Ryan vs. Joey Harrington vs. Chris Redman vs. D.J. Shockley

Alex Smith vs. Shaun Hill

Jon Kitna vs. Drew Stanton

Kyle Orton vs. Rex Grossman

Back up QB Battles:
Brooks Bollinger vs. Gus Frerotte

Luke McCown vs. Brian Griese vs. Chris Simms vs. Bruce Gradkowski vs. Josh Johson

Anthony Wright vs. David Carr vs. Jared Lorenzen vs. Andre' Woodson

Kevin Kolb vs. A.J. Feeley

QB's that could get pushed into a battle at somepoint:

Brodie Croyle/Damon Huard
Kellen Clemons/Chad Pennington
Trent Edwards/J.P. Losman
Matt Schaub/Sage Rosenfels
Derek Anderson/Brady Quinn (I hope not)
Aaron Rodgers/Brian Brohm

[FancyFootball44]

Originally Posted by Browns17

Derek Anderson/Brady Quinn (I hope not)

Why do you hope not? Just curious...

I think if Anderson keeps doing what he did last year, no contest... if he flakes out, Quinn is in. JMO!

[scarletbolt21]

I think Brady Quinn does`nt have the arm for the Browns and DA will have a good year

[Pack Attack]

There won't be a QB battle between Rodgers and Brohm unless Rodgers gets hurt.

I also don't see an Anderson/Quinn battle, either. Not after the monster contract the Browns gave Anderson last year. Quinn will also be an "injury only" replacement this year.

[Browns17]

Originally Posted by Pack Attack

There won't be a QB battle between Rodgers and Brohm unless Rodgers gets hurt.

I also don't see an Anderson/Quinn battle, either. Not after the monster contract the Browns gave Anderson last year. Quinn will also be an "injury only" replacement this year.

That's why I said they could be pushed into situation some point throughout the year. I did not have them listed as QB battles.

[Browns17]

Originally Posted by FancyFootball44

Why do you hope not? Just curious...

I think if Anderson keeps doing what he did last year, no contest... if he flakes out, Quinn is in. JMO!

I just don't want it to happen, because we don't know how Quinn will be.

[Pack Attack]

Quinn looks great in the Subway commercials!

[The Legend Killer]

Colt Brennan looked damn good last night, so did campbell.

[Irish]

Originally Posted by The Legend Killer

Colt Brennan looked damn good last night, so did campbell.

Brennan was beastly. His throws were pretty much all on point. But, all the QBs looked good for the Skins. Campbell has to start worrying

[Eksynyt]

Brennan is gonna see the field this year and might be starting a lot sooner than initially thought. The kid looks legit as long as he has time to throw.

[SmithNHackett]

Originally Posted by Eksynyt

Brennan is gonna see the field this year and might be starting a lot sooner than initially thought. The kid looks legit as long as he has time to throw.

yeh

[scarletbolt21]

I didn`t expect him to be that good.

[Vito2212]

Originally Posted by The Legend Killer

Interesting to see if any of the rookie QB can become the starter of thier new teams.

Some of the "starters" may be unseated, any correct me if I am wrong in guessing.

Colt Brennan VS Jason Campbell ~ Washington

John David Booty VS Tavarius Jackson ~ Minnesota

Brian Brohm VS Aaron Rodgers ~ GB

Chad Henne VS John Beck ~ Miami

Matt Ryan in Atlanta

Joe Flacco in Baltimore

Does aynone think any of these rookie has a legit chance to start.

Allow me to stary from the top:
Jason Cambell has barely played at all this season so far, hasn't since he was injured, and even then he was the best option for them, therefore, i don't see Colt coming in and stealing the spotlight from him.
Jackson seems to be loosing popularity as this preseason goes on, especially with the possibility of a Brett Favre Trade looming, so its all up in the air, if i was head coach right now though, I would probably go with Booty though.
Again, the Brett Favre issue arises. IF Brett isn't on his way to another team by then end of the season, he will be the starter at GB, if Brett isn't there, Aaron Rodgers is going to be using what I am calling his god given right to lead the Packers into the Monday night battle v. Minnesota...
Chad Henne in Miami, nuff said, they needed a QB, they got prob the best Drop back and passer kind of guy they could get coming out of college. He Started all four seasons he was at UM, he will be starting come September for the Dolphins.
As far as Matt is concerned, he has been promised the starting job since he was drafted, he was the best QB on the board on draft day, they took him for a reason, he will start.
Joe Flacco could also be starting come the start of the season. Although Kyle Boller and Troy Smith are the experienced guys, i could see Joe under center week one, although i would love to see the former Heisman winner get the start as well.