Skins 2008

This is how I rank the 4 starting QBs at this time in the NFC east please let me know if you agree or disagree.

1. Donovan McNabb- Despite getting injured often the last 3 seasons still the most talented QB in the NFC East
2. Eli Manning- May have finally come into his own in the playoffs and SB.
3. Tony Romo- Needs to win a playoff game to be considered elite.
4 Jason Campbell- Has outstanding upside but needs to make better judgement late in games and needs to take the Skins to the playoffs before he moves up the list.

SkinFan26

Romo should be no.1 , Eli no.2, Mcnabb no.3 and campbell no.4

__________________
It's better to have lived to see him then to have lived without him. 21

scarletbolt21

Eli should be at the top he`s the only QB with an SB win then Donovan cause he got to SB and Romo third, he`s a good QB but has to improve in the playoffs.

SkinFan26

This is just like in the NBA, Tracy Mcgrady is an all star basketball player is considered one of the greats but can't get out of the first round of the playoffs and the same goes for Tony Romo he is a pro bowler but is held down by the postseason

__________________
It's better to have lived to see him then to have lived without him. 21

Blaze_1UP

Eli > Romo

__________________

Your gonna take a pound'n if you ride bulls for a liv'n, thats juss the way it is.

Goose

Romo has shown more than Eli, but if you want to put Eli in front of him I can't argue that... Eli did win the SB. Romo is clearly better than McNabb and Campbell at this point. McNabb is on the last leg of the downside of his career, he was at one time better than Romo has ever been, but as of right now you'd be insane to take McNabb over Romo. Campbell is a chump, nuff said.

willybeamin

I think it goes like this

Eli
Romo
McNabb
Campbell

I want a QB that doesn't just get me to the playoffs but gets me through it. Romo is good in the regular season but always declines towards the end then takes a *** in the post season. I love McNabb but he is declining fast. Campbell can be good with some decent coaching.

BigdaddyQH

Eli is #1. He got his team to the promised land. Romo is #2, but a choke artist who is more interested in his social life than his team. This is his "make or break" season. McNabb is finished. He is very injury prone now, and can not scramble. He did fine last year, after the Eagles were out of it and no one cared. Campbell certainly has the potential, bu he needs some help and guidance.

__________________
Winning is the Only Accpetable Result

scarletbolt21

I really dont see anything in Cambell, he was never worth it to me.

Skins 2008

Campbell reminds me of a young Doug Williams of 1979 when he became an elite QB. He has the potential to be the 2nd best QB in the division in the future behind Eli Manning. Romo is doing well now but remember there is a reason he wasn't drafted in the first place and he hasn't won a playoff game with a good Cowboys team.Like I posted earlier I put McNabb first because despite his injuries he still is the most talented QB in the division but since Eli won the SB I will put him as the No 1 QB instead of him..

Redskins 1970

^^^
I agree Jason Campbell also reminds me of Doug Williams I think if he continues to develop he can be a very good QB he won't ever be great but I think he can win a SB in the future if he has the right pieces around him.

PhillyLion82

1. Eli Manning- After winning the SB. Eli proved he is a SB QB
2.Donovan McNabb- Injury after Injury the guy is a fighter He has already proved he is playoff potential
3.Tony Romo- Besides coughing the ball on a fake field goal and just plain choking. Romo is a guy you shouldn't really underestamate This year I see Dallas goin far in the Playoffs.
4.Jason Campbell- The guy is good. Needs to take the Skins farther in the playoffs in the future.

__________________

#8Penn State (11-1 BIG TEN CHAMPS) Philly Eagles (6-5-1) Cavs(14-3) #17Villanova Wildcats(7-0)

Transplanted Caper

While I think Romo is the better QB, I can acknowledge that with his ring, and his play in the playoffs, that Manning is deserving of the top spot entering the season. He's followed by Romo. McNabb was a Top 5 QB a few years back, but now? Not so much. He can't stay healthy at all.

__________________
Just because your voice reaches halfway around the world doesn't mean you are wiser than when it reached only to the end of the bar. - Edward R. Murrow

BBSooner

That looks about right. I think they will be different over time, but good for now.

__________________
~BOOMER SOONER~

hit_'em88

Romo=OVER RATED.
maybe most undeserving of hype of all QBs in NFL

__________________