trade calvin johnson for coles?

[fstep]

i got offered to trade calvin johnson for coles
being that coles is hurt and not practicing and favre hasn't had a chance to get the timing down with him is this a good trade

note: i already have roy williams if that makes a big diff...

[The Legend Killer]

Don't do it.

[Irish]

Two WRs on the same bye week with Jon Kitna throwing to them...for Coles, who hs Favre throwing to him, and won't be inactive the same week as Williams (as far as I know)....Dont do it

[K2 4MVP22]

Don't do it. Reason being Calvin Johnson has been in the league for a year now, I believe he's going to have a stand out year. He going to show his first round talent. Roy Williams is also great to have, because he is in a contract year. He is going to put up numbers if Kitna can get him the ball. I wouldn't trade Johnson for Coles though, try and get something bigger out of it considering you already have Roy Williams.

[Goose]

I am going to disagree... I'd do it. First of all didn't Calvin get hurt this week? I thought I saw that... but Favre makes a below average WR look great, Coles has above average skills but hasn't had anyone that could throw the ball more than 20 yards for the last few seasons. I have Coles on my fantasy radar... I expect probably 60-70 catches for right at 1,000 and 7-10 TDs. That will be better than Johnson.