Portis/Harrison for Barber/Chambers

[SDK_06_CHAMP]

What do you think of this deal?

Clinton Portis and Marvin Harrison for Tiki Barber and Chris Chambers

Who is getting the better end of that deal and why?

[Ghost X01]

keep portis and harrison, i think they will be promising for the rest of the season. i dont kno too much about the other two so you should ask around.

[SDK_06_CHAMP]

you dont know tiki barber or chris chambers?

[Ghost X01]

i kno who they are but i havent been following them this season...lol

[Brown_23]

The season is one week old......

Anyways, lets do a comparison. RB's first....

Tiki Barber - 31 Yrs.

2002 - 1387 Rush YDS 4.6 AVG 597 Rec - 1984 Total YDS, 11 TD'S
2003 - 1216 Rush YDS 4.4 AVG 461 Rec - 1677 Total YDS, 3 TD'S
2004 - 1518 Rush YDS 4.7 AVG 578 Rec - 2096 Total YDS, 15 TD'S
2005 - 1860 Rush YDS 5.2 AVG 530 Rec - 2390 Total YDS, 11 TD'S

AVG - 1495 Rush YDS 4.7 AVG 542 Rec - 2037 Total YDS, 10 TD's

Clinton Portis - 25 Yrs.

2002 - 1508 Rush YDS 5.5 AVG 364 Rec - 1872 Total Yds, 17 TD's
2003 - 1591 Rush YDS 5.5 AVG 314 Rec - 1905 Total Yds, 14 TD's
2004 - 1315 Rush YDS 3.8 AVG 235 Rec - 1550 Total Yds, 7 TD's
2005 - 1516 Rush YDS 4.3 AVG 216 Rec - 1732 Total Yds, 11 TD's

AVG - 1483 Rush YDS 4.8 AVG 282 Rec - 1765 Total Yds, 12 TD's

They look comparable. If Portis is healthy he is as dangerous as ever as teams are going to have to respect Was passing game this year. Portis injury to me almost wipes out the age difference as Tiki torch still looks more than solid and is one of if not the best receiving back in the league. I consider these two equal, but would give the edge to barber if you can secure Jacobs as a handcuff. Jacobs will be a serious threat no more than two years from now. Otherwise play the Portis injury game, which this week seems to be better. How long is the better question of the two....

I'll compare your receivers in a moment and give my final answer.